HRT for menopause vs non-hormonal options: what each does and who it suits
HRT for menopause replaces the estrogen your body stops making. It is the most effective treatment for hot flashes and night sweats, and it prevents bone loss. For most women under 60 or within 10 years of their last period, benefits outweigh risks. If HRT is not for you, CBT, clinical hypnosis and newer non-hormonal medicines also work.
General information, not medical advice. Stop if you feel dizzy or unwell, and ask a professional about any health concern.
Maybe a friend swears HRT gave her life back. Maybe your mother was told it was dangerous. Maybe you just want to know your options before your appointment. This page lays out what hormone therapy is, what it does, the real size of the risks, and the non-hormonal routes that work, so you can walk in and have a clear conversation.
What HRT is
Hormone replacement therapy (HRT), also called menopause hormone therapy, gives back the estrogen your ovaries stop making. Three facts shape the choice:
- If you still have a womb, you take estrogen plus a progestogen (combined HRT). The progestogen protects the lining of the womb.
- If you have had a hysterectomy, you take estrogen on its own.
- If you still have periods, you usually start on sequential HRT (progestogen for 10 to 14 days of each cycle) and move to continuous HRT after menopause.
| Form | How you use it | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Tablets | Once a day | Slightly raise clot and stroke risk |
| Patches | On the skin, changed every few days | No added clot risk |
| Gel | Rubbed on the skin daily | No added clot risk |
| Spray | On the arm or thigh daily | Estrogen only, no added clot risk |
| Hormonal coil | In the womb, lasts years | Can provide the progestogen part |
| Vaginal estrogen | Cream, tablet, pessary or ring | For dryness and bladder symptoms; no progestogen needed; does not treat hot flashes |
What HRT does
The North American Menopause Society calls hormone therapy the most effective treatment for hot flashes, night sweats and vaginal symptoms, and says it prevents bone loss and fracture. The NHS adds that it helps keep muscle strength and is especially important for women whose menopause came before 45. NICE tells doctors to offer HRT to women with hot flashes.
Most women feel a difference within days to weeks. Sleep often improves as night sweats ease. For the bone side, see the bone density guide.
The real size of the risks
The fear around HRT goes back to headlines about a large US trial in the early 2000s, whose women averaged 63. The current picture from the NHS:
| Risk | What the NHS says |
|---|---|
| Breast cancer | Combined HRT: about 5 extra cases per 1,000 women after 5 years; risk falls after stopping. Estrogen-only: little or no increase |
| Blood clots | Tablets slightly raise the risk; patches, gels and sprays do not |
| Stroke | Tablets slightly raise the risk, still very low under 60; patches, gels and sprays do not |
| Heart disease | Little or no effect |
Timing matters. The NAMS statement says the balance is favourable for women under 60 or within 10 years of their last period, and less favourable when HRT is started after 60 or more than 10 years after menopause. HRT is not used to prevent heart disease, breast cancer or dementia. It is also not contraception: if you still have periods, you need separate protection.
Who may be steered away from HRT: women with a history of breast cancer, a past clot or stroke, active liver disease or unexplained vaginal bleeding. These are conversations, not automatic no's; your doctor weighs them with you.
The non-hormonal options that work
The Menopause Society reviewed every non-hormonal option in 2023. Here is what made the recommended list:
| Option | What it is | What trials showed |
|---|---|---|
| Menopause-specific CBT | A short course (4 to 6 sessions, group or self-help book) that changes how you respond to flashes | Hot flashes became much less of a problem; an unguided booklet worked for working women |
| Clinical hypnosis | Relaxation and cooling imagery, with a therapist or a daily audio | Flash frequency fell 74% vs 17% with attention alone; a 20-minute daily audio cut scores 53% vs 41% with a sham |
| Fezolinetant, elinzanetant | Pills that block the brain signal (NK3) behind hot flashes | About 2 to 3 fewer moderate to severe flashes a day than placebo |
| Low-dose antidepressants | Certain SSRIs and SNRIs | Fewer flashes; one low-dose type is approved for this use |
| Gabapentin | A nerve medicine, usually started at bedtime | Fewer flashes |
| Oxybutynin | A bladder medicine | Fewer flashes; long-term use is a concern in older women |
| Weight loss | If you carry extra weight | Recommended; more belly fat goes with more flashes |
NICE recommends menopause-specific CBT alongside HRT or instead of it, and fezolinetant when HRT is unsuitable. The hypnosis and CBT guide explains how to access both.
What did not make the list: herbal supplements, soy and acupuncture. They did no better than placebo or sham, or their trials disagree. See the supplements guide for the details.
HRT or not: a quick comparison
| HRT | Non-hormonal medicines | CBT and hypnosis | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hot flashes | Strongest effect | Good effect | Flashes bother you far less |
| Night sweats and sleep | Strong | Some help | CBT for insomnia works well |
| Bones | Prevents loss | No effect | No effect |
| Vaginal dryness | Yes (also vaginal estrogen) | No | No |
| Prescription | Yes | Yes | No for self-help formats |
Many women combine them: HRT plus daily movement, or CBT plus a medicine. A calm daily practice and good sleep habits sit well beside any choice.
Questions to ask your doctor
Bring your list. The US Office on Women's Health suggests covering your symptoms and how much they bother you, your health history (cancer, clots, heart disease), any hormone therapy you have used, and the date of your last period.
- Is HRT a good fit for me, given my age and history?
- Which form would you suggest, and why: patch, gel or tablet?
- Do I need a progestogen, and which kind?
- How soon should I notice a difference, and when do we review?
- If HRT is not right for me, which non-hormonal option would you pick?
- Is menopause-specific CBT available near me or online?
- Should I have a bone density scan?
You do not need a blood test to start: NICE says perimenopause is identified from symptoms and cycle changes in women over 45. A two-week record of your symptoms makes the conversation faster. The menopause symptom score gives you a clear summary to bring.
Questions people ask
Is HRT safe?
For most healthy women under 60, the NHS says benefits usually outweigh the risks and serious side effects are rare. Combined HRT adds a small breast cancer risk, about 5 extra cases per 1,000 women after five years. Patches, gels and sprays do not raise the risk of clots or stroke.
How quickly does HRT work for hot flashes?
The NHS says symptoms usually improve within a few days or weeks of starting. It can take a few months to find the type, form and strength that suit you, so plan a review with your doctor after the first months.
Can I take HRT in perimenopause?
Yes. Women who still have periods are usually given sequential combined HRT, with progestogen for part of each month, then switched to a continuous type after menopause. NICE says perimenopause can be identified from symptoms and cycle changes after 45, without blood tests.
What can I take instead of HRT for hot flashes?
Menopause-specific CBT and clinical hypnosis are the recommended talking options. Medicines include fezolinetant and elinzanetant, which block a brain signal behind hot flashes, plus low-dose antidepressants, gabapentin and oxybutynin. Weight loss also helps. Your doctor matches the option to your health.
How long can you stay on HRT?
The NHS says women typically take it for 2 to 5 years, and longer in some cases. There is no fixed cut-off; review it with your doctor each year. About half of women find hot flashes return for a while when they stop.
Sources
- NHS: Types of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) Estrogen-only vs combined HRT, the forms (tablets, patches, gel, spray, coil, vaginal), sequential vs continuous, typical length of use.
- NHS: Benefits and risks of hormone replacement therapy (HRT) Breast cancer, clot and stroke risk by type and form, little or no effect on heart disease, symptoms easing within days or weeks.
- The North American Menopause Society 2022 hormone therapy position statement (Menopause) Hormone therapy is the most effective treatment for hot flashes and vaginal symptoms and prevents bone loss and fracture; favourable under 60 or within 10 years of menopause.
- The Menopause Society 2023 nonhormone therapy position statement (Menopause) Recommended non-hormonal options: CBT, clinical hypnosis, some antidepressants, gabapentin, fezolinetant, oxybutynin, weight loss.
- NICE NG23: Menopause, identification and management Offer HRT for hot flashes; consider menopause-specific CBT; fezolinetant when HRT is unsuitable; no blood tests needed to identify perimenopause after 45.
- Office on Women's Health: Menopause symptoms and relief What to bring to the appointment: symptoms and how much they bother you, health history, hormone therapy used, time since your last period.
Made by EASYTECH, who also make Second Spring.