Awake at 3 a.m.: should you stay in bed or get up? How to choose, and what to do either way

Should you get up if you can't sleep? If you feel calm, stay and rest, aiming for rest instead of sleep. If you feel tense or cross with the bed after what feels like 20 minutes (two or three turns), get up, sit somewhere dim, and go back when your eyes are heavy. Never time it by the clock.

General information, not medical advice. Stop if you feel dizzy or unwell, and ask a professional about any health concern.

You have been awake a while. Maybe a flash woke you, maybe the bathroom, maybe nothing at all. Now the question arrives: lie here and hope, or get up? Sleep clinics and sleep psychologists give two answers, and both are good. Here is how to choose at 3 a.m., and what to do on each path.

The two paths in one table

Stay and restGet up for a while
Pick it whenYou feel fairly calm and the bed is comfortableYou feel tense, restless or cross with the bed
The goalRest, not sleepBreak the link between bed and wakefulness
What you doLights off, slow easy breath, a body scan or a calm imageDim room, a chair, a paper book or gentle stretching
When it endsSleep comes, or you start to fight itYour eyes feel heavy, then back to bed
ClockTurned awayTurned away

Path 1: get up after about 20 minutes

This is the rule you will find in sleep clinics, in the NHS and in women's health factsheets. If you cannot sleep within about 20 minutes, leave the bed, do something relaxing somewhere else, and come back only when sleepy. Repeat as often as you need through the night.

Why it works: after months of bad nights, the bed itself starts to signal "awake and worried". Leaving the bed when you are wide awake breaks that link, so over a few weeks the bed signals sleep again. In a large analysis of 241 insomnia trials, this rule (called stimulus control) was one of the parts of CBT for insomnia that raised the odds of recovery.

The 20 minutes are felt minutes. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says perceived time, "rather than clock watching". A simple gauge: if you have turned over two or three times, that is about 20 minutes.

What to do out of bed:

  1. Go somewhere comfortable with a low lamp. Bright light wakes the brain.
  2. Pull on a layer if you cooled down after a sweat. Being cold makes the chair miserable.
  3. Do something quiet and a little dull: a paper book, gentle stretching, quiet music, sorting a drawer.
  4. Skip the phone, email and news. They grip you instead of letting you go.
  5. Go back when your eyes are heavy, not when you think you should.

Path 2: stay and rest

Two clinical psychologists who work in sleep medicine put it this way: change the goal from sleep to rest. Trying to sleep gives your brain a task to monitor, and monitoring takes alertness. The harder you try, the more awake you get.

This idea has its own trials. In "paradoxical intention", people stay in bed and drop the effort to sleep, even trying gently to stay awake with eyes open. Across 10 trials it brought large improvements in insomnia against no treatment and moderate ones against other treatments.

What to do in bed:

  1. Turn the clock away and leave the phone face down. Knowing it is 3:47 only starts the sleep math.
  2. Say the moment to yourself. "I'm awake. That's normal in these years. I can rest."
  3. Soften the body. Unclench the jaw, let the shoulders drop, let the bed hold your weight.
  4. Hand on your belly. Let it rise and fall. Make each out-breath a little longer than the in-breath, with no counting unless counting calms you.
  5. Give the mind one light job. Walk slowly through a house you love, room by room, or picture a cool place in detail. A vivid, specific image occupies the mind better than "think of nothing".
  6. Park tomorrow. If the to-do list starts, tell it: tomorrow, in daylight.

If after a while you notice you are fuming, switch paths. There is no failure in getting up.

If heat woke you

Deal with the body before choosing a path. Covers off, turn the pillow, a sip of water, change a damp top. A flash typically lasts 1 to 5 minutes, and most women can settle once it passes. The full routine is in what to do after a night sweat.

Make the choice in daylight

The worst time to decide is 3 a.m. Decide now, while you are calm:

  • Which path will you try first?
  • If you get up, where will you sit? Put a lamp, a blanket and a book there tonight.
  • What sits by the bed? Water, a dry top, a towel.

Then the night holds no decisions. You follow the plan.

The morning after

Get up at your usual time, within about half an hour, however short the night was. Keep your plans; cancelling the day makes the next night more loaded. A tired day is uncomfortable, and you will get through it. Calmer self-talk helps: "This is tough at the moment, and it will pass."

When the nights keep coming

Waking in the night is normal. If long wakings hit three nights a week for three months, that has a name, chronic insomnia, and a treatment that works in women with hot flashes: CBT-I for menopause. To find out what keeps waking you in the first place, see why you wake at 3 a.m. in perimenopause.

Questions people ask

Is it better to stay in bed or get up when you can't sleep?

Both work as ways to stop fighting sleep. Getting up after about 20 minutes is the sleep-clinic rule and part of CBT for insomnia. Staying and resting with no goal of sleep suits many women, especially when the bed feels pleasant. Choose by how you feel: calm means stay, tense means get up for a while.

How do I know 20 minutes have passed without a clock?

Use felt time. If you have turned over two or three times, or you notice you are getting annoyed, that is your signal. Looking at the clock raises worry and makes you misjudge how long you have been awake, so keep it turned away.

What should I do when I get up at night?

Sit somewhere comfortable in low light, keep warm if you run cold after a sweat, and do something quiet that does not grip you: a paper book, gentle stretching, quiet music, folding laundry. Skip screens and work. Go back to bed when your eyes feel heavy.

Should I sleep in after a bad night?

Get up at your usual time and keep the day's plans. Sleeping in shifts your body clock and makes the next night harder. If you nap, keep it short and before mid-afternoon.

Sources

Made by EASYTECH, who also make Second Spring.